‘Asleep at the wheel’ Bedford councillors clash over withdrawal of Local Plan 2040

Withdrawal of Local Plan 2040 branded a loss of democracy in council row

Bedford borough councillors have clashed over claims of “loss of democracy” following the withdrawal of the Local Plan 2040.

Bedford Borough Council and inset, councillor Doug McMurdo and mayor Tom Woottonplaceholder image
Bedford Borough Council and inset, councillor Doug McMurdo and mayor Tom Wootton | Iconic Media Group / Bedford Borough Council

At a Full Council meeting on Wednesday (November 11), councillors discussed the implications of new national planning legislation, which came into force on October 31. The mandatory changes will affect planning applications and determine which applications are discussed in council by elected representatives.

Conservative councillor Doug McMurdo argued that Bedford borough’s democratic safeguards had already been weakened last year due to the withdrawal of the Local Plan 2040, leaving the authority without the strategic planning framework and five-year housing land supply he said were needed to protect local communities from development.

He also questioned whether the authority had already experienced a loss of democracy under the previous administration.

Cllr Doug McMurdo said: “That was a tremendous loss of democracy because of the portfolio holder for planning, Mayor Wootton’s failure – fell asleep at the wheel, I think, has been reported in the press.”

The Local Plan for 2040 was submitted for independent review in January 2023. Following concerns raised by the planning inspector about the solidity of the plan and the deliverability of its proposals, the council voted to withdraw the plan in October 2025.

...democracy was seriously damaged here in this chamber last year

Cllr Doug McMurdo

Doug McMurdo also argued that the decision to withdraw the plan had removed important protections and safeguards for communities, parish councils and elected representatives.

He said: “Our loss of democracy was seriously damaged here in this chamber last year, where we could have had much stronger protection and this may not have been an issue as it is now.

“Because we do not have a local plan, and we do not have a five-year land supply. That is the test. So, any change in legislation is only making things slightly worse.

“That’s when local democracy went. That is the thing that will fail any community going forward”, he added.

Mayor Tom Wootton rejected criticisms, accusing the councillor of shifting responsibility for the failed Local Plan onto the current administration.

In a statement, he said: “The Best Value Inspection highlighted a culture of blame and politicians pointing fingers rather than accepting responsibility and Councillor McMurdo’s comments are a grim reminder of exactly why that culture needs to change.

“Instead of focusing on the task at hand, he was remarkably keen to talk about who was ‘asleep at the wheel’ over the failed Local Plan 2040, but rather less keen to acknowledge who was driving when it was prepared and submitted – himself and the previous Liberal Democrat administration.”

The mayor described the criticism as “political point-scoring” over a plan which he said was faced with fundamental issues from the beginning.

... he was remarkably keen to talk about who was ‘asleep at the wheel’ ... but rather less keen to acknowledge who was driving

Mayor Tom Wootton

Instead, the debate should have focused on ways to protect local democracy in the wake of government planning reforms, he stated.

“Our focus was on ensuring that borough, town and parish councillors retain a meaningful route to raise concerns about significant planning developments following the Labour Government effectively shutting us and residents out of the planning process”, he said.

Mayor Tom Wootton added that an amendment had been introduced in the interest of strengthening transparency and to ensure greater public accountability.

He said: “Residents deserve to know their concerns are being heard, not brushed aside behind closed doors.”

News you can trust since 1845
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice