Three police officers sacked over incident in which man suffered catastrophic neck injuries
Three police officers have been dismissed over an incident in which a man suffered catastrophic neck injuries in an incident outside a Bedford nightclub.
Bedfordshire PCs Hannah Ross, Nicholas Oates and Sanjeev Kalyan were found to have committed gross misconduct for their honesty and integrity in accounts given about the victim’s condition after he was seriously injured in Bedford.
All three were dismissed without notice, while a fourth officer, Sgt Andrew Withey, was given a final written warning.
Julian Cole was seriously injured in an incident outside Elements nightclub on May 6, 2013.
None of the officers were accused of causing the injuries following lengthy investigations by the Independent Police Complaints Commission (IPCC now Independent Office for Police Conduct - IOPC) and Crown Prosecution Service (CPS).
A misconduct hearing heard how the three officers had arrested the 19-year-old Mr Cole and taken him across Mill Street to a waiting police van, following a scuffle involving the officers and door staff at around 1.35am.
Mr Cole was placed into the van and taken to Greyfriars Police Station where an ambulance was called.
The officers were accused of breaching their code of conduct for honesty and integrity for accounts they gave of Mr Cole’s condition following the incident.
They were found to have lied about Mr Cole’s condition in statements in their pocket notebooks and/or during interview.
They were all found to have breached the standard concerning duties and responsibility amounting to misconduct in relation to failing to carry out adequate welfare checks.
PC Ross was cleared of using excessive force for her use of handcuffs on Mr Cole.
Sgt Andrew Withey, who was dealing with other elements of the incident while Mr Cole was arrested and taken to the van, was found to have breached the code of conduct for failing to carry out welfare checks on the teenager when he was at the back of the van. The panel ruled that his conduct amounted to be misconduct and he was given a final written warning.
Assistant Chief Constable Jackie Sebire said: “At the centre of our thoughts today are of course Julian Cole, his family and friends. This case is an absolute tragedy, which has had a devastating effect on a young man and his loved ones, and we should not forget that.
“That said, there are a number of things to highlight about this case. Firstly, it is entirely right that proper independent investigations were carried out, to collect and review all of the evidence impartially and decide whether there was any criminal conduct, professional misconduct, or any actions which could have prevented this awful situation and, crucially, whether any lessons could be learned to prevent such an occurrence happening in the future.
“This hearing in essence reviewed a seven minute encounter which took place more than five years ago, and I agree with the panel that the length of time the IOPC and CPS enquiries have taken to get to this stage is simply unacceptable to Mr Cole, his family, the officers concerned and the force. On far too many occasions investigations such as these take years to come to a resolution and this cannot be right.
“It is clear that no evidence was found that any of the officers involved were in any way to blame for the catastrophic injuries suffered by Mr Cole.
“This misconduct hearing focused on the actions of our officers in the care given to Mr Cole and their honesty and integrity in the events following his injury. I apologise that their conduct following the incident fell well short of what we expect at Bedfordshire Police.
“Honesty and integrity is vital in policing. The public should be able trust that officers will always be truthful and open and act professionally at all times. Police officers must display the highest standards of integrity and truthfulness and three of our officers have faced the consequences of being found not to have done that today.”