'The wrong time and we can't afford it' Call for referendum over Bedford's mayoral system defeated

A motion seeking a referendum over whether Bedford’s directly elected mayor system should be replaced by a council leader and executive, was defeated at an extraordinary full council meeting.

The motion was presented last night (Wednesday) by Labour Cauldwell councillor Abu Sultan, but was lost with 16 votes in favour, 24 against and four abstentions.

Bedford Borough Hall and inset, mayor Tom Woottonplaceholder image
Bedford Borough Hall and inset, mayor Tom Wootton

Councillor Sultan said: “This isn’t about the current or previous mayor or who might be mayor tomorrow, next year or at the next election.

“It’s certainly not about settling a political score with any particular person. This is about the system of governance itself.

“Mayors, councillors and political parties change, but the governance structure of the council can remain in place for decades. We’re saying the people of Bedford borough should have that opportunity again to say how they want their council governed.”

The mayoral governance of the town’s local authority was introduced in 2002, with Conservative Tom Wootton appointed to the role at the 2023 elections.

In July, he vowed to stay on, despite a vote of no confidence.

The meeting heard from the council’s monitoring officer that the estimated cost of holding a public referendum would be around £375,000.

Independent Sharnbrook councillor Doug McMurdo warned: “Putting any burden of this magnitude on the Bedford borough taxpayer is very ill-thought-out. It’s just such bad timing. We cannot afford it.”

The mayor questioned the public demand for governance change, saying: “There’s a petition calling on this council to hold a referendum on the mayoral system, which had 171 verified signatures earlier today.

“The statutory threshold for residents to trigger such a ballot through a petition is 6,940 electors, five per cent of the electorate.

“That’s not evidence of overwhelming public demand for a referendum. We’re being asked to use the votes in this chamber to settle what the public campaign has come nowhere close to achieving.

“Neither is distracting this council for months with an argument for which the public has shown so little appetite. So let’s not manufacture a constitutional crisis where residents haven’t asked for one.”

Green Party Greyfriars councillor Ben Foley explained: “The qualities required to win an election are very different to those needed to lead an administration of an efficient council.

“If any mayor isn’t up to the job, we’re stuck with them until the next election. There’s nothing anyone can do to force them out, even if they’ve lost the support of their own party.”

Liberal Democrat De Parys councillor Henry Vann said: “This debate is distracting us and officers from the issues in hand.

“What makes this even more absurd, amid the calls of apparent democracy from the Labour Group, it doesn’t stack up when you first move a procedural motion for a secret ballot.

“The fundamental reality of being accountable for the decisions you make is so important. We’re bound to be transparent. I was shocked and appalled by that attempt at a procedural game.

“It’s not something we’ve time to look at currently. It would be a rushed job, while on a wet, windy, horrible November evening, goodness knows what the turnout would be in a referendum.

“Imagine what that £375,000 could be spent on. Labour voted for two of the budgets which drove us to bankruptcy and abstained on the third.

“This is the wrong time. We can least afford it. Devolution will inevitably mean we revisit the subject in the future.”

News you can trust since 1845
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice